Review: The Lives of Others

By Kelly FitzGerald

Winner of the 2007 Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film, Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck’s The Lives of Others (2006) impresses on many fronts. Painting an honest portrayal of raw human compassion, viewers witness the transformation of an emotionless Stasi Captain, Gerd Wiesler (Ulrich Mühe), into a man capable of sympathizing with the subject of his self-motivated investigation.

Gerd Wiesler (Ulrich Mühe) bei seiner Arbeit.

Gerd Wiesler (Ulrich Mühe)


Introduced as a cold-blooded interrogator, Wiesler’s distinguishably militant demeanor is mirrored through the mundanity of his wardrobe, dominated by shades of gray, clean lines and the occasional spy accessory (namely headphones). Everything about him is painfully calculated, from his thought process to the way he walks. His capacity for human emotion appears non-existent as he instructs aspiring Stasi officers on methods of interrogation, distrustful of a student who displays a glimmer of compassion. Like his code name which is reduced to a series of letters and numbers (HGW XX/7), Wiesler’s character forces audiences to question what makes a human being more than just a name or a cog in a machine.

Sebastian Koch’s character, Georg Dreyman, offers a possible answer to this question. An East German playwright whose works are also read in the west, Dreyman acts as a foil to Wiesler through his marriage to the arts and human well-being. Emotionally motivated after learning about the suicide of blacklisted friend and theater director, Albert Jerska (Volkmar Kleinert), Dreyman chooses to join a movement in revealing East German oppression as influenced by the DDR. While this strand is essential in driving von Donnersmarck’s compelling narrative, Dreyman is more of a moral coach in what is truly Wiesler’s story. Though the two are never on screen at the same time, Dreyman transmits hope and compassion across the socialist synapse which, for Wiesler, is the barrier between a life of discipline and one of fulfillment.


Georg Dreyman (Sebastian Koch)


Perhaps the unofficial title for von Donnersmarck’s film should be Sonata for a Good Man, the name of the song that Jerska gifts to Dreyman before his suicide, also the title of Dreyman’s book. As stated in a review by The New York Times, Mr. von Donnersmarck’s film is “haunted” by the notes of this song, which Dreyman plays as a tribute to his deceased friend. Listening through the wires of his bugged apartment, Wiesler is moved to tears as he builds a connection to Dreyman through the language of music—a language that ascends letters and numbers. Just moments later Dreyman poses the most memorable question of the film, “can anyone who has heard this music, I mean truly heard it, really be a bad person?” As evidenced by the softening of what once appeared a stone-carved face, Wiesler’s tears provide an answer to Dreyman’s question: anyone who has truly heard the music is not really “a bad person.”

Mr. von Donnersmarck’s heartwarming narrative can be extended to the greater social workings of Germany circa 1984, inviting viewers to entertain the possibility that not all socialists were bad people—and if they were, that there was still a seed of goodness planted within their hearts. In The Lives of Others, art transcends political structures because it is a basic element of the human condition—it’s fruits dependent on that which is incalculable.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Review: The Lives of Others

  1. mediaphiles says:

    Kelly, I find your review to be incredibly insightful. I have not seen his film, but your analysis of the characters and the plot have sparked my interest. I really like how your review is detailed, but still doesn’t give the full storyline away. In addition, the article you cited was incorporated quite efficiently into your review.
    -Allie Kleinman

  2. mediaphiles says:

    I found this review to be very detailed and substantial. I have never seen this movie before but I understand the political nature and serious undertones within the film. I thought that your take on what the unofficial title for the movie was very clever and I look forward to reading the additional review you linked!
    -Courteney Case

  3. mediaphiles says:

    Love how you add the connection to the song and propose it as an alternate title–clever transition to discussion! I thought your review was rich and informative, and a good sell for the movie! I especially appreciated your incorporation of the human condition–it adds a beautiful, relatable layer to your review.

    -Meg Schmit

  4. mediaphiles says:

    Your review has definitely got me adding this film to my “Watch Next” list. I am a firm believer in the power of compassion and gray areas between good and evil, so it will be interseting to see a movie that also explores these topics. The quote about music seems so real, especially because I too have realized I shared similar music tastes with my “enemies”.
    –A.P. Brothers

  5. mediaphiles says:

    I saw this film this past summer and really enjoyed it. Your review is extremely well done. I think Wiesler is one of the most interesting character put to film in recent years. I think his character ark is fascinating.

    -Walker Rise

  6. mediaphiles says:

    This seems like a great film. I enjoyed your analysis and description of Weisler, as he seems like a very interesting character. I also liked how you showed Dreyman to be a foil to Weisler. Great review, I plan to watch this movie now!
    – Peyton Perea

  7. marymdalton says:

    It really is a terrific film. Put it on your must-see list!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s